Saturday, March 26, 2016

Carl von Clausewitz - On strategy in general




Chapter 1: Strategy

  • strategic theory deals with planning
  • a true mark of wisdom is to do just enough to accomplish an objective without trying to do more than current strength and resources allow

Chapter 2: Elements of strategy

  • moral elements = everything that is created by intellectual and psychological qualities and influences
  • physical elements = the size of the armed forces, their composition, armament and so forth
  • mathematical elements = the angle of lines of operation, the convergent and divergent movements wherever geometry enters into their calculation
  • geographical elements = the influence of terrain, such as commanding positions, mountains, rivers, woods, and roads
  • statistical elements = support and maintenance.

Chapter 3: Moral factors

  • moral factors are inseparable from war
  • wisdom is cultivated not so much by critical studies, but by insight and flashes of intuition

Chapter 4: The principal moral elements

  • they are: the skill of the commander, the experience and courage of the troops, and their patriotic spirit
Chapter 5: Military virtues of the army

  • military virtues are different than simple bravery
  • military virtues are found only in regular armies
  • military spirit is a critical element of war, and it is built by victorious wars and frequent exertions of the army to the utmost limits of its strength
  • don't confuse the real spirit of an army with its mood
Chapter 11: Concentration of forces in space

  • being strong and keeping one's forces concentrated are the decisive factors in strategy
  • concentration of force is the norm, and every separation and split is an exception that has to be justified
Chapter 13: The strategic reserve

  • the 2 purposes of a reserve are to prolong and renew the action and to counter unforeseen threats

Chapter 14: Economy of force

  • always ensure that all forces are involved, that no part of the whole force is idle
  • wasting forces is worse than using them improperly
  • completely inactive troops are neutralized, while even the smallest action can detract from the enemy's strength and focus
Chapter 16: The suspension of action in war

  • both sides can't take same actions simultaneously. If one advances, the other is waiting
  • politically, only one can be the aggressor: there can be no war if both parties seek to defend themselves.
  • violent clashes are interrupted by periods of observation, during which both sides are on the defensive

Source(s):


Monday, March 7, 2016

Carl von Clausewitz - On the theory of war


This post continues with a summary of the second book in Clausewitz's treatise, that deals with the theory of war:

Chapter 1: Classifications of the art of war
  • the art of war is the art of using the given means in combat
  • the distinction between tactics (the use of armed forces in the engagement) and strategy (the use of engagements for the object of the war)
  • classification between combat activities (marches, camps and billets) and maintenance activities (supply, medical services and maintenance of arms and equipment)
  • war activities classified in preparations for war and the actual war
Chapter 2: On the theory of war
  • the use of intellect in warfare
  • the need to create a system of theoretical principles for the conduct of war
  • the role of theory is to guide someone who wants to learn about war, not to formulate the actions on the battlefield
  • theory studies the nature of ends (victory) and means (the fighting forces)
Chapter 3: Art of war or science of war
  • war is neither an art nor a science, but a clash of interests in the humans' social existence
Chapter 4: Method and routine

  • a method or ‘mode of procedure’, is a constantly recurring procedure that has been selected from several possibilities.
  • routines represent a general way of executing tasks as they arise based on average probability.
  • constant practice leads to brisk, precise, and reliable leadership
  • routine is better suited for tactics than for strategy
  • a certain amount of subjectivity that reflects the personality of the commander exists in his actions. That style may not suit those who copy it

Chapter 5: Critical analysis

  • critical analysis = the application of theoretical truths to actual events
  • 3 steps in critical approach: 1) the discovery and interpretation of equivocal facts (historical research); 2) tracing effects back to their causes (critical analysis proper); 3) investigating and evaluating the means employed (criticism)
  • A critical inquiry––the examination of the means––poses the question as to what are the peculiar effects of the means employed, and whether these effects conform to the intention with which they were used.
  • a critic should analyze the reasons why an exception occurred

Chapter 6: On historical examples


  • historical examples provide the best proof in empirical sciences. They can be used as an explanation of an idea to show the application of an idea, to prove the possibility of a phenomenon or effect, or to deduce a doctrine

Source(s):
On War

Friday, March 4, 2016

Carl von Clausewitz - On the nature of war


Prussia has produced notable personalities that influenced history, such as chancellor Bismarck and general Clausewitz. This is the first post in a series that focuses on Carl von Clausewitz's military theory treatise, On War. Here I summarize the contents of the first book, that discusses the nature of war.

Chapter 1: What is war?
  • the definition of war
  • acknowledges the need for the maximum use of force
  • it is through their interaction that warring sides push each other to extremes
  • the aim is to overcome or disarm the enemy (making him defenseless)
  • was is not an isolated act and it doesn't consist of a single decisive blow
  • the result of war is not final
  • the similarity between war and a gamble
  • war as a means of reaching a political goal
Chapter 2: Purpose and means in war

  • the 3 objectives that must be considered: the armed forces, the country, and the enemy's will
  • war doesn't involve the notion that the 2 states have relatively equal strength
  • methods to increase the cost of the war for the enemy
  • combat is the only means of war
Chapter 3: On military genius

  • military genius consists of a combination of elements that influence military performance
  • war being the realm of chance
  • the importance of the intellect in war
  • the role of the commander
  • temperament and feelings's influence in war
  • relationship between warfare and terrain
Chapter 4: On danger in war

  • the effect that immediate danger has on the mind of a soldier
Chapter 5: On physical effort in war

  • physical effort can't be measured
  • hardships are no excuse for a defeat, bu they boost the value of a victory
Chapter 6: Intelligence in war

  • the unreliable character of information in war
  • most intelligence is false, and reports of bad news multiply easily
Chapter 7: Friction in war

  • even the simplest thing is difficult in war
  • how performance in war is lowered by many factors 
  • habit and experience are essential for sound decision-making

Chapter 8: Concluding observations on Book One
  • danger, physical exertion, intelligence, and friction are the elements that impede activity in war. They can be countered by combat experience


carl von clausewitz


Source(s):
On War